I liked "Tipping tips from the gratuity guru" published Friday, September 25, 2009 -- except for the Dusty Wallet tip at the end. I'm glad you consulted Stephen Dublanica and mentioned his book, Waiter Rant; which I read recently and enjoyed.
However, the Dusty Wallet tip about buying yourself gift cards to avoid tipping does a disservice to servers. I assume you intended it as a joke because it is obviously incorrect when you think about it, but unfortunately many people will not realize this because who has time to think these days? Why should servers not receive a tip on the portion of the bill paid by a gift card? "The food and service industry seems to have no mechanism yet for deducting a tip," does not mean the server does not deserve a tip nor that you do not owe one. The food and service industry doesn't (normally) automatically deduct a tip from cash payments of any kind, but you still tip. And if for some technical reason a tip can't be paid from your gift card, then give cash for the tip.
Regards,
David Ellis
Updated September 30, 2009
Received the following prompt reply from Gary Marr, the author of the "Tipping Tips" article:
Thanks for reading.Perhaps I took the Dusty Wallet tip too seriously. I'm sure no harm was intended but I'm afraid many readers are all too ready to rationalize not tipping or tipping less than a fair amount. I wish the institution of tipping did not exist, because it confuses and embarrasses me. But because it does exist, service workers depend on tips to make a living wage.
The Dusty Wallet is always a bit tongue-in-cheek. I was talking about Starbucks and places like that. I wasn’t condoning it but when you use your gift card there, there is no mechanism for a tip. For now.
The tipping topic has generated no end of comments. I wish I had the definitive answer on tipping! I don’t.
Cheers,
Garry

